Poll: Who is the most obvious non-canon ship on the web?

unnamed With a deep appreciation for the wonderful world of fandoms, we are putting out a poll in efforts to sniff out Who the most obvious non-canon ship on the web is. Our last poll collected over 92,623 votes when we determined Who the most popular lady loving ship on the Internet wasShipping, after all, is a huge part of fandom. In this poll, we are looking deep into the subtext of storylines and the obvious onscreen chemistry between different pairings that aren’t official couples (but probably should be). These non-canon ships each have fandoms filled with great gif sets, excellent fan fiction and fan videos made that certainly support the whole shipping thing. From viewing movies such as Pitch Perfect to television shows such as Once Upon a Time, fans know the familiar wave of feelings that overtakes them when they find themselves saying three fateful words: I ship it. The next thing you know, the non-canon ship becomes your OTP (one true pairing) and you’re living for updates in Tumblr tags and multi-chapter fanfics. We feel you. So let’s take a look at the ships in the poll (or you can skip right to the voting page) and figure out just Who is the most obvious non-canon ship on the web?

TheHollywoodMag brings you entertainment news and fun stories


  1. jo

    August 4, 2015 at 4:08 pm

    Yesss, Swan Queen! You’ve got this SWEN. 🙂

    • Kali

      August 5, 2015 at 9:53 pm

      Is swan queen wins does this mean it will make them a real couple on the show

      • Eli

        August 6, 2015 at 10:17 am


        • Miranda

          August 6, 2015 at 11:07 am

          No they will not be canon if they win. It’s up to the people who make the show to decide what couple is canon and which is not. This poll is just a poll run by a magazine and not the show itself, winning the poll won’t make it canon. I’m sorry it’s the truth!! Swan Queen is not the story they are telling and they have said it countless times and all the polls and tweets and stuff won’t change their mind.

          • Jo

            August 6, 2015 at 3:15 pm

            Oh my Goodness stop. Just stop. A simple no to that question would’ve sufficed.

            Are you a writer on the show? Do you have some sort of special ability to see the future? No?

            Sit down.

          • Regina

            August 7, 2015 at 11:55 am

            SwanQueen actually is a huge story they’re telling. That’s why there’s 1000s of people in countries around the world that see it. That’s why more and more journalists also see it. Whether it’s ever to be romantic or not remains to be seen because the writers have not ever once stated it can’t/won’t happen. But SwanQueen is a canon story. SwanQueen is a canon relationship, perhaps the strongest and most developed on the show. 4 years strong.

          • Deco

            August 7, 2015 at 4:27 pm

            Miranda? 3 Things:

            1) It was a joke, I’m pretty sure. No need to belabor the obvious.
            2) You’re not “sorry” at all. Stop with the faux sympathy.
            3) Will you defend the writer’s right to tell their story as strongly IF they DO decide to go with overt SQ romance??? Or suddenly, will your support of their artistic integrity go *poof* like so much magical purple smoke?

    • Maria

      August 16, 2015 at 9:57 pm

      No! Xena and Gabrielle are true winners in this poll. Swan Queen is just a made up fan ship by a group fans who constantly push their agenda on to Adam and Eddy. I have been a Xenite forever and the Xena/Gabrielle fans are better behaved then any of the Swan Shippers who constantly send hate to the actors and cast and to other fans because other people dont think like Swan Queen shippers.

  2. femslashgoggles

    August 4, 2015 at 4:25 pm

    Xena and Gabrielle don’t belong in this poll. They were canon. Hell, they transcended what is considered simply canon with their love spanning eons, continents, alternative universes, and continuing even after reincarnation. Go watch Xena again is what I’m trying to say and experience one of the most amazing love stories unfold before your eyes again.

    • Kyle

      August 4, 2015 at 6:51 pm

      I agree. Xena/Gabrielle are canon. The actresses said it, the writers said it.

      • TheHollywoodMag

        August 4, 2015 at 7:06 pm

        As a Xena/Gabrielle shipper, it’s also my head canon they were married — and while on the show, they were canon soulmates — they were also canon ‘best friends’. It was the early 2000s and they never officially called them a couple on the show — hence why they qualified for the poll.

        But yes, anyone who actually watched Xena should know that they were in love, together and married (with a child).

        Honestly, I’ve got into many heated discussions with general television viewers who have insisted their friendship was intimate but they weren’t lovers. Obviously, I disagree and think they’re together — but because of that gray to some — is why they’re in here 🙂

        • Miranda

          August 6, 2015 at 11:09 am

          I think they belong, I never saw them as a romantic couple but as best friends

    • Blair

      August 5, 2015 at 12:01 pm

      Yep. They were a thousand percent an obvious relationship. the true OTP

      • Deco

        August 7, 2015 at 4:29 pm

        A CLASSIC, iconic, ultimate, quintessential OTP! 🙂

  3. Scarlett

    August 4, 2015 at 4:37 pm

    I wouldn’t include Emma & Regina from OUAT. The connection & chemistry between Emma & Captain Hook is through the roof. It’s impossible to picture Emma w/ anyone else at this point, especially after all the buildup to that epic “I love you” in the season finale. Captain Swan is by far the most romantic couple on TV.

    • Nahhh

      August 4, 2015 at 4:50 pm

      The season finale that stated ‘actions speak louder than words’ & had Emma say ‘I love you’ to Hook…

      Before sacrificing her life & soul so that Regina could have her happy ending?

      Just like Regina gave up her happy ending for Emma when she gave Emma all her memories of Henry, & multiple other instances of them sacrificing for each other.

      The ‘buildup’ to Captain Swan consisted of Hook being horrible to Emma, before deciding he liked her, & then stalking her & insulting her until she gave in & said yes to him.

    • ml

      August 4, 2015 at 4:54 pm


      • Yahhh

        August 5, 2015 at 4:22 am

        Clearly someone didn’t pay attention to what Jennifer Morrison the woman whom plays Emma has said that she did it for everyone, not just Regina. Oh and don’t you dare try to dismiss the “I love you” as Jennifer Morrison has gotten upset when people like you SQ fans try to dismiss her canon romance which she loves very much.

        So sorry that she doesn’t see your crack ship nor like it. If you honestly think she likes your crack ship all I have to say is LOL!

        • Regina

          August 5, 2015 at 9:10 am

          Looks like someone came here to start fights where someone obviously doesn’t belong. This poll is for non-canon romantic ships. If you can’t play nice and if can’t bother to look up what a crack ship really is then go back to Twitter or FB and chat hatefullly with your CS friends. This poll is for people that have bigger and better imaginations then what canon gives us. Bye now and happy canon shipping.

        • supernana

          August 5, 2015 at 11:14 am

          1) Clearly someone didn’t pay attention to what Eddy Kitsis the MAN WHOM WRITE THE SOHOW has said “….so that when Emma sacrificed herself for Regina’s happiness based on a pledge she made…..” (http://coalitiongirl.tumblr.com/post/124033882103/great-another-wedding-x) And I’m sorry, I respect Jennifer and her interpretation but HIS vision is more accruate since he’s the freacking WRITER OF THE WHOLE DAMN SHOW (with Adam)

          2) Clearly you don’t respect Jennifer Morrison’s wishes for everyone to respect every ships and shippers. Clearly, you’re implying that Jennifer is the kind of person who just hate/don’t care for a large part of her fanbase when she stated again and again that EVERY fans is important to her.

          3) Clearly you didn’t understood that this “Who is the most obvious NON-canon ship on the web” poll is NOT THERE FOR YOU and your “ooooh so perfect and epic canon ship!!1!!”.

          • Zahc

            August 5, 2015 at 11:40 am

            Jennifer morrison has called out csers twice.Once against real life shipping, which they, and their fangirl reporter leanne, still do.Second time when they basically body shamed the actress with the Emma preg rumours, Jennifers response to that was precious.
            Jennifer has sided with SQ many times, coleman fkery, she publicly slammed savior queen homophobic fkery, Jennifer was also first to respond to red valentino sweater tweet…and there are many other examples that shows Jennifer support to her SQ fans.I don’t know why these haters are trying to pass her off as a hater which IF ANYONE KNOWS A THING ABT HER WILL KNOW SHE IS NOT.
            Stupid being.

          • Zahc

            August 5, 2015 at 12:08 pm

            Wow ‘genius’ individual ever heard of PR that the actress are PAID to do, the only thing Jennifer cares a about is Emma Swan and ALL HER FANS as she has repeatedly stated but for ‘geniuses’ like you and your delusions…lol..no hope for that.
            If Jennifer receives a script tomorrow that has Hook stupidly swallowing his well hook and dying bet you a 1000, Jen will be like “Hook died okaaay” her loved boring romance LMAO.

        • ml

          August 5, 2015 at 12:27 pm

          I can’t believe you responded to my “lmao” in a huff omg y’all need to chill. lmao.

    • Avril

      August 4, 2015 at 4:55 pm

      “Poll: Who is the most obvious non-canon ship on the web?”
      All you gotta do is read the title of this article to see that this has nothing to do with other canon pairings. THM are focusing on non-canon fan favorites so to state that you wouldn’t include Emma/Regina is irrelevant –because they ARE a non-canon fan favorite. The fanbase revolving around the relationship between these two characters is huge, (stated by The Hollywood Mag) and therefore you should not be suggesting the disinclusion of this pairing. Please don’t invade this kinda space which is /clearly\ for the fans of non-canon ships. Cheers 🙂

    • Regina

      August 4, 2015 at 5:24 pm

      Please refrain from telling other fans how to fan and think that your opinion and interpretation on what constitutes chemistry overrules what 1000s of other people see because apparently multiple people think Emma/Hook are nothing special including me and see tangible evidence that SwanQueen could and would happen in a more accepting world. See, we all have opinions. I wouldn’t go to a poll to tell you you’re wrong so how about the same courtesy. Thank you. Happy shipping.

      • kyle

        August 4, 2015 at 7:28 pm

        SQ very well may be in the 1 million fan range. Making it one of, if not ‘the’ largest ship on the show.

        • Lauren

          August 5, 2015 at 4:16 am

          LMAO okay. I wonder where you got that info from. SQ does not have a million fans you have absolutely zero proof to state this.

          • maria

            August 5, 2015 at 11:43 am

            yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen

            any resemblance to real events and/or real persons is not purely coincidental

          • Emma

            August 5, 2015 at 2:00 pm

            Pretty much Lauren… Seriously Kyle do you do anything else with your life then sit on social media all day and harass writers and actors into making your ship cannon. Oh that’s right you use bots to win polls to prove your ship is cannon when in reality no one gives a rats ass about your abusive incest shit ship.

        • Laura

          August 5, 2015 at 4:26 am

          Oh delusional Kyle. You keep on blabbing about these millions of fans but still have not shown me any proof. So you might want to lay off because most people in that watch the show don’t even know the SQ fandom exists,lol.

          • maria

            August 5, 2015 at 11:42 am

            yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen

            any resemblance to real events and/or real persons is not purely coincidental

          • Yeaa

            August 5, 2015 at 1:10 pm

            but imagine how easy it would be to open the audience to that possibility, emma has already sacrificed herself for regina’s happiness “you worked too hard for your happiness to be destroyed”, people are raptly paying attention to sq bc it’s one of the most prevalent parts of the show – all the audience would need is a hint that it could be romantic and they’d follow the road. i wouldn’t write it off so fast buddy!

      • Helga

        August 5, 2015 at 4:24 am

        You can also refrain from telling others that SQ would happen in a more acceptable world. THE WORLD IS FICTION! It’s created by two people, that have already shown these woman in loving and healthy relationships that even the actresses embrace and respect. Maybe the fans should start or just stop watching the show. You sound very ignorant right now Regina I hope you know that.

        • Regina

          August 5, 2015 at 9:20 am

          Well hello there Helga. I think you missed a few interviews. JMo has stated that she respects our ability to interpret this show any way we like and Lana loves all her ships including really loving SwanQueen. If you don’t think that the show would play around more with SwanQueen, even if just bts, in a more ACCEPTING world then you’re living in a different world. See when I pointed out above that this was just my opinion it was an attempt to say that we all have them and one person’s opinion doesn’t overrule. You’re still trying to tell fans how to fan. Try to understand context a bit more before telling someone they are ignorant or you just come off sounding just that, ignorant. Also, how about you stop coming here and to start insulting people. Bye now and happy shipping.

    • Oh sweet summer child

      August 4, 2015 at 5:46 pm

      This is sad.

    • Regina's idiot

      August 4, 2015 at 6:05 pm

      and WHO CAAAARES? lol This is a poll for not-canon ships. Do you want an award for best lesbian couple too? come back when there’s a poll for “best liar” and you’ll find hook. Until then….mind your own business.

      • Vykieeeee

        August 5, 2015 at 5:22 am

        😀 hehhee, well said 😀

        • Kat

          August 5, 2015 at 3:33 pm

          Haha. Well said. Tho I believe cs had at one point an argument that their ship is queer aka lgbt if Emma is bisexual so it wouldn’t surprise me that they would want an award for best lesbian couple.

          Lol. Cs and OQ are so pathetic. Thanks for the page views guys. You make us even more popular with your hate. Not to mention that everyone knows what a hateful little bunch you are.

          Maybe Hollywood magazine would like to write an article about how hateful cs and OQ are that they feel the need to invalidate even a poll that’s about non-canon ships. Either way win win for SQ. So thanks a lot.

          Also you guys voted riziles you realise most sq shippers ship that just as much as sq and want it canon right? Again sq shippers win again.

          Go back to your ship and enjoy it. Nice seeing how obsessed you are Lauren or should I say addicted oncer

    • Emma

      August 4, 2015 at 6:38 pm

      1) if you think Emma and Hook have chemistry you should try watching season 1 again. The sexual tension between Emma & Regina is just insane. And you wanna talk about connection? Emma and Regina have a relationship built during 4 seasons, real development (but you probably don’t know what that is), they share a son, and they have so many things in common…
      2) It may be impossible for you to picture Emma with someone else at this point, but is not impossible for many many fans of OUAT that ship SwanQueen or other ship involving Emma, or that simple don’t like CS
      3) epic “i love you” seriously??? “ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS” is all I’m gonna say
      4) If you really think they are the most romantic couple on TV you don’t know what romance is, and I feel sorry for you!! It’s pretty sad actually

      why invade this space??? This is about non-canon ships??? CS is really THAT boring that you have to worry about SwanQueen 24/7?

      • Jodie

        August 5, 2015 at 8:04 am

        Completely agree.from episode 1 season 1 emma and regina had serious sexual chemistry they even very nearly kissed. The whole how do i get her to taste my forbidden fruit I mean come on.
        As for saying cs is the most romantic couple on tv lol bs
        ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS meaning she may have told him she loved him BUT she sacrificed her soul and herself to save REGINA .
        I feel sorry for u if u think cs is romance.
        Sq is true love and is one of the biggest fandoms since fayberry in glee.
        U must b blind if u dont see it seriously. In the meantime leave r ship alone and jog on

      • Skye

        August 5, 2015 at 9:18 am

        Damn right!!!

      • Kate5

        August 5, 2015 at 3:30 pm

        Oh my God yes. CS is the most boring ship on OUAT. There is no chemistry I dont know how people see chemistry between Hook and Emma but still…

      • Amalee

        August 6, 2015 at 11:12 am

        Let’s not forget in the S4 finale when Hook (who didn’t know how to use a sword) went to face off against Charming and Emma was like, “‘Kay, thanks!” Whereas when Regina was threatened she pulled out her sword and went to battle.


        BUt for real, ship and let ship and quit being oversensitive babies. Shit (this does not apply to the comment I am replying to).

    • Kyle

      August 4, 2015 at 6:54 pm

      Why are you here then? Last time I checked, no one gave a hot crap about the fan service ily between SeeAss. For the last few months, all anyone has been talking about is how Emma gave up her soul to save Regina.

      This article, along with 10+ others have been written calling for #SwanQueen to be made canon. While just as many articles have been written calling CS boring, a waste of time, and needing to end.

      CS is an epic failure, with dropping ratings, and clear indifference from the general audience.

      But thats my opinion, backed up by ratings and articles. As is this is ‘your’ opinion, back up by…..

      • Lauren

        August 5, 2015 at 4:18 am

        Oh Kyle delusional idiot Kyle. I really would like to see these 10 +articles calling for SQ being canon because the only one I’ve seen is from some person that works at Bustle which hate to break it to you hun is bottom low when it comes to media outlets. She’s just stating her irrelevant opinion much like you. SQ will never be made canon on the show Kyle.

        • Regina

          August 5, 2015 at 9:22 am

          Lauren, I’ll help you out. When you start your opinion with personal insults to another commenter, most people stop reading. Go back to your CS friends and hate on SwanQueen somewhere else. This is a space that doesn’t include CS so why are you here? Methinks it’s just to cause problems.

          • Bradamant

            August 5, 2015 at 3:21 pm

            You know, that’s very true. I read the first five words of her comment and then my eyes skipped on to the next comment, yours in this case, and loled when I read your “When you start your opinion with personal insults to another commneter, most people stop reading.”

        • maria

          August 5, 2015 at 11:43 am

          yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen yell SwanQueen

          any resemblance to real events and/or real persons is not purely coincidental

        • Zahc

          August 5, 2015 at 12:15 pm

          Guys here’s the delusional who believes she writes the show.
          Aww..poor being insecure about her canon ship and trolling articles where nobody,like the show’s general audience, gives AF about her bore ships;)

        • MissAbbs

          August 5, 2015 at 1:33 pm

          Why are you even here?!

        • Kyle

          August 5, 2015 at 1:56 pm

          …Why are you saying my name so many times, weirdo? And yes, there are that many articles written for SQ. Is vastly popular. More so then your canon crap. That most burn.

        • Escueto

          August 5, 2015 at 3:22 pm

          Hi, even if it doesn’t become canon;
          Can you ask yourself why do you take pleasure in coming here, and telling lesbians they have to wait another 200 years to see what you see everyday on TV. Relationships that resemble you and move your deeply and inspire you.

          I doubt i ever did anything to you personally.
          And yet, i have to come here, smile (Cuz yes, this is my happy place, SQ is my happy place), and get exited that my ship might win. To then go to the comment section and see you here screaming at us, that i won’t get it.

          “SQ will never be made canon on the show”
          What is it to you? Does our joy about something really piss you off that badly?
          Please, reconsider your stance.

    • Jimmy

      August 4, 2015 at 7:33 pm

      Emma and Hook have ZERO believeablity! Ever since they made her “show interest” I’ve been gagging AND I’M A GAY MAN WHO IS ATTRACTED TO HIM!!! They just don’t fit, but that’s an opinion and I totally respect yours! Even if I am surprised by it!

      • Asher

        August 5, 2015 at 2:12 pm

        Colin is too beautiful for that terrible ship. I think he would have been a better fit with Lana actually,

        • Bradamant

          August 5, 2015 at 3:23 pm

          But it’s not about the actor: Hook has been a really poorly written character. I wouldn’t wish him on any character I actually liked . . .

    • emma

      August 5, 2015 at 3:55 am

      this is like showing up to a baking contest and saying you don’t think the cakes should be included because you prefer sausages. if you’re so committed to the sausages, why are you at a baking contest? go hang out at a sausage fest.

      • Regina

        August 5, 2015 at 9:29 am

        Award for best comment goes to ^^^

      • TheHollywoodMag

        August 5, 2015 at 9:30 am

        (while we can’t get involved with the actual debate — it must be pointed out that this comment is amazing)

      • maria

        August 5, 2015 at 11:27 am

        I bow to you

      • MissAbbs

        August 5, 2015 at 1:36 pm


      • Michelle Vee

        August 5, 2015 at 10:12 pm


      • Lexi

        August 6, 2015 at 10:17 am

        Best comment of the year.

      • keeva99

        August 7, 2015 at 9:51 am

        hahahahahahahahhahahahhahahahahaha…perfect comment is perfect 😀

    • linda

      August 5, 2015 at 10:26 am


    • Ghost of the evil queen

      August 5, 2015 at 10:38 am

      Honey, your ship is canon. This isn’t about canon ships. Go home and learn to read.

    • Kay

      August 5, 2015 at 12:02 pm

      Why are Craptain Swan shippers here? Do you guys have to ruin everything, even in polls where your prcious CAANON ship is not included? JFC you guys spend too much time shitting on a ship that by your judgment will “never happen”.

    • harshymcharsherson

      August 5, 2015 at 12:04 pm

      Here I was, enjoying my voting fun, but now the Craptain Swan rape shippers have arrived! It’s threatening for you to see that a subtext story is far more popular than your grotesque little creation ain’t it? Swan Queen is THE story on television right now and your little blip of nonsense doesn’t even register. Troll and poll invasion be damned, huh Scarlett? Or is that you, Mikey? The same guy who threatens femslash fans’ personal safety? Or is it you, skyliange, the blogger who spent the better part of June trying to hack femslash shipper’s accounts?

      • Regina

        August 5, 2015 at 12:11 pm

        Let’s not stoop to their levels with insults. SwanQueen stands on its own merit.

        • harshymcharsherson

          August 5, 2015 at 12:17 pm

          You’ll know exactly who I am if I ask you not to perpetuate micro fascist internal policing against me or others, Regina, so I’ll just whizz away on my motorized armchair to read Swan Queen fan fiction. The real problem with CS’ers in all of this is that they’re dictating what people say and how they’re allowed to say the things that they say. That’s a shame. We deserved better than this mess.

          • Regina

            August 5, 2015 at 1:25 pm

            Lmao!!!! Hat tip to you my lovely. I’ll leave the fascism to the CS shippers from now on. #SwenLove to you ;)))

    • no

      August 5, 2015 at 2:09 pm

      I don’t see the chemistry…. and was more epic the sacrifice she do for regina ‘The actions speak more than words’ 😉

    • Emily

      August 5, 2015 at 3:00 pm

      omg…..there’s a reason they are saying the most obvious NON CANON SHIP. For the love of god, yes we know you are canon. And many would argue that they are far from ‘most romantic’ so please take your opinion elsewhere. Thank you.

    • You failed. :')

      August 5, 2015 at 4:23 pm

      Dude… are we watching the same show? Really, you think Emma and Hook have chemistry? You really think like that? I guess you are one of the people that only likes Hook because he’s hot ,right? Am I right, or wrong? About what you said :
      First : Why are you here? Really… why the fuck are you here?
      Second : Hook and Emma don’t have chemistry. Hook is Emma’s puppy.
      Third : ‘Actions speak louder than words’, nothing else to say.
      Fourth : Captain Swan didn’t exist ’till the third season. SwanQueen is ‘ON’ on the first episode, do you remember? ‘Pilot’
      Fifth : I don’t know if you get this but… you are really being hated in the SwanQueen fandom… :v You better read what you write before publish it. And… you better know what you’re doing when you enter in some poll that doesn’t even is about your shipp. 🙂
      You better take care of it. Cause really… you made a really ugly thing here… 😀 Hahaha. :’) I love see CSers being fucked by Swens. I love u all SQ family. <3 Go cry to your fandom… Bye. Be happy with your no-sense shipp. :')

    • Mari

      August 5, 2015 at 5:04 pm

      I had to stop reading at the “the connection & chemistry between emma & captain hook is through the roof”. Sorry.

    • Tess

      August 5, 2015 at 8:54 pm

      Heey, if you want to trade places and put Hook and Emma here and get Regina and Emma in canon, boy, be my guest!

    • Mary

      August 9, 2015 at 11:51 am

      LOVE LOVE LOVE Colin, but their chemistry really isn’t great. Emma/Graham or Emma/Neil were way more believable and it seems they kept Hook only for the pretty… no development story line whatsoever.
      To be fair, the strongest chemistry Emma has had with a guy is August. Such a shame they can’t be a couple.

      They really should introduce some more fitting pairings on this show. Hook/Emma and Hood/Regina are really weak and strange. The two strongest leads deserved greater partners. Or no love interests at all! Their need to make romantic couples just for the sake of it, no falling in love, no development, no partnership, seems like the show is made for teenage fan girls only.
      It had such and epic potencial in season 1…
      Anyway..Really hope Emma’s endgame is someone else. This one is kinda mediocre.

  4. maria

    August 4, 2015 at 4:45 pm

    love protective attraction care friendship mutual understanding

    thanks hollywoodmag

  5. henry baker

    August 4, 2015 at 5:03 pm

    maura said many times she loved jane so you could say rizzoli and isles is canon also

    • TheHollywoodMag

      August 4, 2015 at 7:10 pm

      platonic friends can exchange ‘I love yous’ — their romantic relationship still isn’t canon though. maura and jane’s chemistry is off the hook — I ship it!

  6. Syd

    August 4, 2015 at 5:12 pm

    Emma & Regina are yin and yang of the show, literally. The hero & the villain, savior & evil queen, now the dark one Emma & the hero/savior Regina. They were enemies in the first season, now they are friends. That development was massive, bittersweet, continuous with ups and downs and they may not be in a romantic relationship but this relationship is more real, deeper and more meaningful than those ‘canon’ ones they have.

  7. Ginger

    August 4, 2015 at 6:56 pm

    Xena and Gabrielle don’t belong in a poll for non-canon ships. You could’ve done Xena/Ares or Gabrielle/Joxer but Xena and Gabrielle were a couple.

    • Blair

      August 5, 2015 at 12:02 pm


  8. Kyle

    August 4, 2015 at 6:58 pm

    I think #SwanQueen is the best ship on OUAT. Its got a following around 1 million, 1000s of works of fan fiction, 1000s of works of fanart, and some of the highest rated episodes in the series.

    No sane person can doubt the level of chemistry between these two characters, nor the obvious subtext for SQ and the clear camera angles and lines given between these two characters.

    ): )

  9. aikanoff

    August 4, 2015 at 7:31 pm

    as Xena fan I’ll vote for Xena/Gabrielle also like OUA

  10. Jimmy

    August 4, 2015 at 7:35 pm

    I am going to need Lucy Lawless and Renee O’Connor to reprise their roles for a Xena revival! I am not sure they qualify as “non-canon,” but they are certainly the most obvious NON RECOGNIZED canon!!

    • harshymcharsherson

      August 5, 2015 at 12:05 pm

      Yeah they’re non-recognized canon for sure. I hope they bring Xena back with Xena actually WITH Gabrielle and not some sort of younger, straighter version of her.

  11. Shannon

    August 5, 2015 at 12:18 am

    Xena/Gabrielle were my first choice but they were canon so they don’t even belong on the poll as much as I love them! So, I voted for Regina/Emma. SWAN QUEEN. The amount of parallels between Xena/Gabrielle and Regina/Emma is ridiculous. They are meant to be together. There is no way the writers can continue to say it’s unintentional.

    • Tess

      August 6, 2015 at 8:57 am

      Make a post about those parallels and I’ll love you forever!!!

  12. Ifeoma

    August 5, 2015 at 3:28 am

    I voted Swanqueen but R&I, Xena & Gab, infact every pair deserve to be canon.
    Swanqueen has totally eclipsed my heart

  13. #VivaLaSwanQueen

    August 5, 2015 at 4:48 am

    Cmon SwanQueen, you can win this. We are strong. We have power. We have chemistry and yes, we are canon. #VivaLaSwanQueen

  14. Vykieeeee

    August 5, 2015 at 5:19 am

    Well, as a XENA/ARES Shipper for life.. I’ll happily vote against XG for any of the others..
    clearly romantic my ass!! I hate that selfish, hypocritical, irritating blonde.
    XENA’s One True Soulmate is ARES God of War.

    • Bradamant

      August 5, 2015 at 3:29 pm

      Yessss, because Ares was _never_ selfish, hypocritical, or irritating!

      Oh, wait. . .

      • Vykieeeee

        August 5, 2015 at 7:25 pm

        Ares irritating? NEVER. He’s the God of War, give him a break.. he needed some time to adjust to these thing called emotions!! Daaaaa.

  15. Brittney

    August 5, 2015 at 7:27 am

    Rizzles needs to get their shit together and become canon already. They should have been canon in season 2 ffs. And thank god Swan Queen exists because there are so many amazing fanfictions out there written by some amazing writers that I absolutely love. Idc if they ever become canon, even though i highely doubt they ever will, as long as those fanfics keep comming ~ <3

  16. Jodie

    August 5, 2015 at 8:17 am

    Cs has 7.5 k stories
    Sw has 10.5
    So it speaks for itself 3000 more

    • Laura

      August 5, 2015 at 10:49 am

      CS has 7.5 K stories that’s great. But you know we also have the most important story of all, the show where it’s canon which is way more important and relevant then any silly FF.

      • Merwordup

        August 5, 2015 at 12:02 pm

        Laura, your canon relationship of Captain Rape Culture has contributed zilch to increase viewership of OUAT. As a matter of fact, ratings for the show have continuously drop since season 2. Just becuz CS is canon, it doesn’t say much. Considering that the writers have dumb down story lines and plots that attract equally basic people.

      • harshymcharsherson

        August 5, 2015 at 12:53 pm

        Oh please, CSers overtag to promote their hetero invasion. You’re the GOP of shipping movements, trying to convert the gays and destroy Planned Parenthood. Seriously, you people NEED to go away. The Duggars has this whole show just for you! Oh. Wait, oh no, well, never mind.

      • Emily

        August 5, 2015 at 5:47 pm

        Please go take your CS filth somewhere else. Honestly, do YOU not have anything else to do other than troll on polls that have NOTHING TO DO WITH YOUR SHI(T)P?

  17. Regina

    August 5, 2015 at 9:28 am

    Hey all. How about we just enjoy the poll and vote. I know we seem to have attracted many CS trolls, but trolls will do what trolls do.; attack and insult. This poll isn’t about them, I’m not sure why they’re even here unless it’s just to cause problems and fights. I’m sure they’ll be voting for any ship we’re up against. SwanQueen is a beautiful ship for many reasons and it’s getting more media buzz for good reason. Just vote for your ships and ignore the CS bullies. To all other non-canon ships and shippers I say hello from a SwanQueen and Xena fan (although that’s canon:).

  18. Rebeca

    August 5, 2015 at 9:51 am

    I seriously can’t believe that Captain Swan fans came here, a poll where they aren’t even mentioned, just to insult Swan Queen and Swan Queen shippers. You already have your canon couple! Why can’t you let us enjoy our SHIP? LEAVE US ALONE, FOR CHRIST SAKE. We’ve been here since season one! Let us enjoy our ship and mind your business! Damn. I cannot with these people. If you take time to comment on a poll because you hate SQ so much, you’re in need of help. Or maybe do you actually see the possibility of SQ but you’re scared. Either way, stay in your place.

    • Jordan

      August 5, 2015 at 11:05 am

      They don’t like it when things happen in the OUAT fandom that don’t revolve around CS. It’s sad really, they think CS is the be all end all of the show. According to them, if you don’t ship CS, you’re not a fan. In reality though, people outside the CS fandom probably wouldn’t even care if they broke up.

  19. Stacey

    August 5, 2015 at 9:56 am

    First of all why is there c$ people on here anyways? Your just all showing how immature and disrespectful you people really are. And for the umpteenth time lana and jmo love the sq fandom so your arguments are invalid and irrelevant. Now back to voting and showing how beautiful and loving this swen fandom truly is. Viva LA SwanQueen!

    • Oh boy

      August 5, 2015 at 10:56 am

      Yep JMO really loves your ship. That’s why she completely dismisses your stupid Emma saved Regina theory and the whole “actions speak louder than words” thing you guys blab about. She got very upset at that when she was asked by a biased SQ shipper in the media room @ CC and she let her anger be known. She’s dismissed every theory you guys have had.

      While you guys try to say that it was a choice between Hook and Regina. Jennifer got upset because she does not like when people insult her canon romance and she does not like this notion that people try to twist SQ into something it’s not.

      Here’s the vid so maybe you can shut up with the whole Emma chose Regina over Hook thing, it had nothing to do with that. Yet you honestly think she loves SQ, lmao okay.

      Meanwhile Jennifer gushes about CS daily about how Emma loves Hook so truly and so passionately and she knows how much he loves her. You wish she talked about SQ the way she does about CS.

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gx3cIaXqzhM Where Jennifer gets mad at the stupid Emma choosing Regina over Hook question.

      • Regina

        August 5, 2015 at 11:01 am

        Mikey? Is that you? Now back under your bridge and start learning how to NOT twist context to suit your trolling needs. Bye now. Have a nice day and happy shipping.

      • HMMMM

        August 5, 2015 at 11:58 am

        mikey. Why are you here? Go troll somewhere else. Go find something to do positive about YOUR OWN ship. You’re incredibly transparent and you’ve been spouting the same nonsense for months and no one is buying into it.

      • Zahc

        August 5, 2015 at 2:03 pm

        Jennifer gushes about CS really…delusional.Oh and btw learn pr folks actors are paid to promote their current arcs.
        When they kill hook don’t go hating on jennifer cause she will love the no cs show finely.
        BTW saw the vid Jen was more upset abt the line she forgot than the dumhead vs Regina ques.
        But who could argue with the delusionals.
        Oh and stop making urself look stupid Eddie the PRODUCER said sacrifice was for REGINA.

  20. Asher

    August 5, 2015 at 10:51 am

    Dear Captain Swan shippers

    I would like to thank you, on behalf of the #swanqueen nation, for providing yet another example of the commercial viability of swan queen. Hollywood Mag puts swan queen in a poll and us, swen, show up in droves to vote.


    Then you guys show up to vote against us.


    Making swan queen the HOTTEST commodity in town, a sure bet for page views. Meanwhile, anytime anyone wrties anything about your ship, no one but you comes to the party. We stay away.

    When ten more articles follow this one, in publications all over the interwebs, you can give yourselves a sound round of applause for making it happen.


  21. maria

    August 5, 2015 at 11:14 am

    Captain Swan shippers Thank you for showing everyone the real bullies

  22. Lex

    August 5, 2015 at 11:48 am


    Emma and Regina are the cornerstone relationship on the show. It was always to be about them. Emma, The Savior, comes to town and meets Mayor, Regina.

    Everything about their relationship is what epic love stories are made of. Brilliant!

    SwanQueen is MY fairy-tale.

  23. What?

    August 5, 2015 at 11:59 am

    Your choice of wording of the title of this poll is horrible and it doesn’t help that you don’t really explain what you mean by “most obvious” or what qualifies as “most obvious.”

    The person who came up with this poll is obviously stupid.

    • TheHollywoodMag

      August 5, 2015 at 12:04 pm

      Excuse you — my choice of diction was on point and it’s not my issue if you struggle with the wording. The title is very clear and if you are having trouble understanding it, I’m just sorry for you and this poll is probably not for you.

      Also, I don’t appreciate you calling me stupid — it’s both unkind and inaccurate (are these words also hard for you to understand?) sorry, not sorry.

      • Asher

        August 5, 2015 at 2:15 pm

        Hey there,

        That’s just Mikey being Mikey. He doesn’t like women, in general, but he has a particular dislike for female journalists who aren’t talking about Captain Swan. I am sorry that he called you stupid. You did not deserve that.

        • Nope not Mikey

          August 5, 2015 at 2:40 pm

          Don’t know who that is. I’m a woman anyway.

          It is a vague poll regardless of whoever came up with it.

  24. Quin

    August 5, 2015 at 12:12 pm

    Swan Queen all the way.

  25. Troian

    August 5, 2015 at 12:13 pm

    So I just scrolled through all the comments on this non-canon ship poll and I feel like this has been blown way out of proportion. I realise that CS are canon and I’m pretty damn sure every other SQ shipper realises that too, in reality, the only one who doesn’t seem to know that is you because this is a non-canon ship poll, and not a competition as to whether CS should be canon or not. I 100% support every ship on the show and I fully understand that the whole CS fanbase isn’t full of people trying to ridicule and stamp out all SQ shippers. I also know that the CS fans who don’t go out of their way to insult SQ shippers DO stay out of all the hate because THEIR SHIP IS CANON (whether I like it or not) and so, naturally, they don’t feel the need to make people feel bad for believing in something they think is right, they’re just content to watch their ship being canon. So why do the other small percentage of CS shippers continue to insult us? Is it because it makes you feel good about yourself to belittle and bully other people? Or is it because you feel threatened by the outstanding chemistry SQ have? it’s one or the other. Personally, I can see why you ship CS. Although I don’t agree with the way Hook pushed Emma into things at the beginning of the relationship, I do see that Hook’s authoritarian attitude did dumb down towards the end of the season and their relationship has developed throughout the their time together. I acknowledge your reasoning behind CS and I’m pretty sure you know our reasoning behind SQ, so why must we go around in circles trying to prove the same point? Whether SQ is canon or not, it is still something people believe in and something that makes people (whether you like it or not) in and out of the SQ fandom happy. All we’re doing is voting in a harmless (or so we thought..) poll between shows with non canon ships. It seems to me that you’re more anti SQ than pro CS, which is fine, just don’t take it out on people who just want to believe in something. You have what you want (a canon ship) so why are fighting for (because it sure sounds like you are) your canon ship to be canon? Is your ship being canon not enough?

    • harshymcharsherson

      August 5, 2015 at 12:55 pm

      gosh trojan you sure said CANON enough in your comments. And actually, if the #NotAllCSers movement wants to gain steam, they might have to cut down on the organized chaos that they tend to create wherever they go.

  26. harshymcharsherson

    August 5, 2015 at 12:15 pm

    Ummmm, are the Hook stans attacking the author of the poll now? They’re pretty intense about their trolling games. Careful HollywoodMag mod, they’ll go after your accounts next. Obvious is actually an interesting word. For years we would have seen Faberry shippers sweep this kind of thing. They’ve all graduated (we’ve? I suppose) to Swan Queen, Root/Shaw, Clexa, not sure what else, that Carmilla show? Moar and moar representation is always good. Anywaaaaayz I quite liked your use of ‘obvious’ in this case.

  27. swen 1,000,000,001

    August 5, 2015 at 12:46 pm

    Swan Queen all the way.
    Csers thank you for taking the time out of your oh so busy schedules to come visit this poll for non-canon ships. the fact that you care about us enough to make the effort to spend your oh so precious time showering swen with this much attention truly warms my heart.
    All my love
    the millionth and one swan queen shipper.

    P.s. Rizzles I ♥ you too

  28. Swan, We Are Gay

    August 5, 2015 at 1:42 pm

    Wow, glad to see Mikey and Laura all showed up to this party, what a hoot, they must’ve run out of people to troll elsewhere. Oh well. I’m so happy our biggest antis decided to bring us their usual bit of attention. (Seriously those two, we were just doing the usual voting… I wonder how they found out about this, were they on some Swen’s blog or Twitter? Looking for ways to troll people? Must have been.)
    Anyways, I placed my usual Swanqueen vote, read the comments and am leaving to continue enjoying my break. 🙂

  29. Sigh

    August 5, 2015 at 1:47 pm

    Cs shippers leave the stupid sq shippers to their irrelevant poll from an irrelevant magazine with only 118 Twitter followers. We have the show, something they’ll never have no matter how much they bitch and whine on Twitter it’s never going to happen. So just leave them alone, let’s celebrate our tca nomination and also Jennifer and Colin filming today.

    • Zahc

      August 5, 2015 at 2:10 pm

      WOW I ain’t insulting anybody, tho I believe ur worthless, I am known for my ‘goodyness’ my ‘amazingness’ but ain’t gonna say I am modest y’all.
      LMAO yeah thanks for the comment now take ur advice and GTFO

    • Toothy

      August 5, 2015 at 5:46 pm

      I was about to vote for Swan Queen and leave quietly. The usual runaround of “he said/she said” parsing of interviews leaves me cold.

      But your comment went beyond that. Dismissive? Yes. Supercilious? Absolutely! Hateful? Definitely.

      You see, you’ve just called me stupid yet I don’t believe you know me. According to you I’m stupid because I like something different to you; I’m stupid because one of the aspects I enjoy most in OUAT is something that is not canon.

      Why does this make me stupid? Has MENSA started using a new Intelligence Quotient measure based on what someone does/doesn’t like in a fictional TV show? If so, I’ll need to upgrade my membership!

      Do I hate/dislike or otherwise denigrate those who ship Captain Swan? No, why would I want to do that? It’s clear that it’s popular, I simply don’t ship it, that’s all. But it appears that, for you, what people do or don’t like in a TV show leads you judge whole swathes of them as stupid. You’re definitely not starting your assessment from the first principles of scientific methodology.

      I would also like to comment on your use of the term “irrelevant”. If we are, why did you feel the need to comment? Surely, by any normal definition of the word, irrelevance should render the need to comment superfluous.

      I, however, felt the need to comment because you called me stupid.

      Captain Swan has received lots of nominations recently, and I’d like to say congratulations for those. I also wish you all the best for the upcoming season of OUAT, enjoy what has been written but, please, try to lay off of the disrespectful comments.


    • Roia

      August 6, 2015 at 9:52 am

      ^^This post.^^

      “Anyway I didn’t want your STINKY toy!”

      *throws toy across the room and stomps foot*

  30. Jeanne

    August 5, 2015 at 1:48 pm

    Great poll! Thanks for recognizing so many beautiful non-canon ships! I ship them all, but SwanQueen will always be my #1

  31. Zahc

    August 5, 2015 at 1:54 pm

    Jennifer morrison has called out csers twice.Once against real life shipping, which they, and their fangirl reporter leanne, still do.Second time when they basically body shamed the actress with the Emma preg rumours, Jennifers response to that was precious.
    Jennifer has sided with SQ many times, coleman idiocy, she publicly slammed savior queen homophobic nonsense, Jennifer was also first to respond to red valentino sweater tweet…and there are many other examples that shows Jennifer support to her SQ fans.I don’t know why these haters are trying to pass her off as a hater which IF ANYONE KNOWS A THING ABT HER WILL KNOW SHE IS NOT.
    Stupid being.
    GET A BRAIN STUPID and stop trying to demonize a wonderful actress and a better person BY LABELING HER AS A HATER BECAUSE OF YOUR IRRELEVANT SHIP

  32. mustdefine

    August 5, 2015 at 1:58 pm

    I am baffled by CS fandom’s insistence that only canon matters, therefore only their ship matters. If that is so, what merit did CS have before it was canon? If Swan Queen is a “crack ship” that will never be canon, then why are CS shippers so threatened that they feel it necessary to invade a poll for noncanon ships?

    Many in CS fandom seem determined to send us the message that we are unwanted, that we do not matter, that the actresses hate us, that our ship–and more importantly, the (mostly queer) people who ship Emma and Regina–should be silenced and erased. Many in SQ fandom remember a CSer’s anti-SQ post to this effect, cosigned by 900+ CSers. The behavior exhibited in that post is similar to that of these comments. You want us to shut up and go away. Well, we will not; this is a poll for us, and you cannot silence us here or elsewhere.

    Thank you to THM for posting this poll, by the way. I could take issue with Xena/Gabrielle being canon, but I get it 😉

  33. Kyle

    August 5, 2015 at 2:03 pm

    Wow, SwanQueen comments make up most of bulk here. As always, SQ leads the way. Despite the childish actions, and trollish manner of other ships.

    PS: Did a C$ fan actually attack the creator of the poll? Sorry about that. Their…insane. But I find it funny as well that out non canon ship is larger and more popular then their canon one. Says a lot of about their ‘love story’.

  34. .....

    August 5, 2015 at 2:14 pm

    Ouat is a shitty show the only good in it are Swan Queen but they are destroying their characters.

    • Swan, We Are Gay

      August 5, 2015 at 2:36 pm

      Ya sound like an anti. And are likely Mikey. Nice try tho.

  35. Zahc

    August 5, 2015 at 2:40 pm

    They are simply ridiculous, I have seen many fandom wars but these moron csers take it to the next level.
    And speaking on behalf of Jennifer pls remember what happened during ‘colegate’

  36. Zahc

    August 5, 2015 at 3:08 pm

    Also, sorry to burst your bubble, compared to other actors, the promotion Jennifer does for CS is non-existent; no social media promo from her unless it’s absolutely necessary, minimum number of interviews and that too on ouat paid media outlets.It’s like they force her to PR, cause they know she won’t do it on her own.
    BTW Jen did not say EVER that Emma will not make the sacrifice for Regina, she actually HEAVILY INSISTED that Emma will sacrifice for just Regina, their ‘friendship at the moment’ is that important and when darkness surrounded Regina ‘It was a clear choice for her with NO HESITATION ON HER(EMMA’S) PART
    At the time of finale filming Jen was SUPER BUSY and the OUAT script was changed about three times IT IS OBVIOUS JEN DOESN’T REMEMBER THE FINAL CUT (she doesn’t watch the show)BUT SHE NEVER DISCREDITED SWAN QUEEN EVER.
    Stop the lies TROLL

  37. Hell..

    August 5, 2015 at 3:53 pm

    “There’s no reason to create drama so let’s create drama.” This is from a CSer : just why?? It’s a non canon poll, there’s just no reason to pop out saying why SQ isn’t real. I don’t know just ignore it… You’re ruining the fun. As for Jen’s stance it’s her own and you know what? It’s better if we don’t really know what she thinks instead of trying to side her somewhere. Well you may at least say she’s anti bullshit and injustice.

  38. Michelle Vee

    August 5, 2015 at 7:12 pm

    REGINA AND EMMA would be incredible!!! Their chemistry is already off the roof, now imagine if they actually became canon? AMAZING!

  39. ollie

    August 5, 2015 at 8:04 pm

    why do people feel the need to actively vote against a poll they’re not even involved in? i’m not going to say i’m perfect but at least i don’t hold that much hate in my heart.

  40. Grillo

    August 5, 2015 at 8:22 pm

    “You SwanQueen use bots to win polls” says someone in a fandom that multiply twitter accounts as bots and hack twitter and tumblr accounts of SwanQueen shippers, besides harrass, stalk threat…. So smart!

    • Emma

      August 5, 2015 at 9:49 pm

      Whoa dude i’m not even a cser. I’m not even part of your fandom. I’m in another fandom. The once fandom is ruined because of swan queen

      • Grillo

        August 5, 2015 at 10:24 pm

        And I have to believe THAT, talking as hateful as the others. You must be a plot hole then. Oh, it’s caNon, not cannon. You’re welcome.

  41. facebook.com/SimbiAni

    August 6, 2015 at 2:34 am

    Not even gonna cmt on the thousand-year ship wars (the fandoms may change, yet the immaturity is ever the same), ie go into my pov on how both sides have serious issues.. but just had to write in to say, YAY @ Harry/Hermione! xD

    I’m one of those rare fans.. #shipALLtheships! I have my faves (as well as least tolerated, sometimes) but I believe there’s room to respect all varieties, especially with the usually crappy canon writing anyways (ongoing inconsistencies & major plotholes, drama for the sake of drama.. sooo frustrating, but they can still manage to inspire such fun creativity from fellow fans!). And just to clarify, that’s why I watch- for the actors, the addiction, & the inspiration ;P

    But because so many fandoms tend to be ruined by the ~crazy shippers, particularly ones supposedly on “my” teams (& definitely prefer to avoid being lumped in with them!), I really don’t interact as much as I’d like. Eh well..

    My ships, as relevant to this poll:

    HP ~ Ron / Hermione / Harry / Draco

    OUAT ~ Regina / Emma ( / Killian )

    XWP ~ Xena / Gabrielle ( / Joxer )

    & not mentioned:

    SPN ~ Castiel / Dean ( / Sam )

    H50 ~ Danny / Steve ( / Catherine )

    Yes, I often end up OT3/4-shipping, lol just cannot resist.. I love most the idea of happy snarky families being awesome together & saving the day! #dorkyeverafter #externaldramaonly #cantwealljustgetalong #hopelessoptimist

  42. Cora

    August 6, 2015 at 3:21 am

    Viva la Swan Queen!

  43. doug morris

    August 6, 2015 at 5:20 am

    I voted for Xena and Gabrielle!

  44. fiftyshadesforonce

    August 6, 2015 at 11:45 am

    As a CS shipper, I want to ask my fellas to stop generating ship wars again(!) when it’s unnecessary!! We have nothing to do with this poll. As stated before, it is for non-canon couples.
    Apologies for the SQ shippers. Such bad form is not acceptable.
    Ship and let ship!
    (ps. I might have voted for you…)

    • Tess

      August 6, 2015 at 11:01 pm

      Much love to you, fellow oncer. I might go vote for CS in the next canon poll as a personal thank you to you.

  45. Steph86

    August 6, 2015 at 3:10 pm

    Honestly I love Gab and Xena, but I don’t see them in a romantic way. Well, I ship them in that way, too, but for me they are soulmates (and that doesn’t mean they are lovers, too). Her bond is more than a sexual love.
    By the way, I voted for Swan Queen. And I really don’t know way CS shippers are here, when this poll is about NON-CANON ships. Swan Queen is not canon, but it is a very important ship. The fandom is big and so it is quiet normal that the ship is winning. IMO they have an incredible chemistry, they are the ying and the yang of the show (even if I see Emma and Lily as soulmates, considering the fact that they are connected since the beginning), they are a very well-develop relationship, they saved each other life several times, their bond is now very strong. Emma’s sacrifice was the best scene in this 4th season. Yes, she made a sacrifice for the whole town, but it is clearly for Regina’s happiness, too. That’s my opinion. And no, I really don’t see the chemistry between Hook and Emma. I felt more chemistry between Emma and Graham (they were a very nice couple. I loved him). You should respect everyone’s opinions and I am talking to the CS shippers as well as to the SQ shippers who should not have replied to some comments.

  46. Just a shy SwanQueen fan

    August 6, 2015 at 5:34 pm

    Hey y’all Just here to spread some SwanQueen love and ignore the haters. Lets share our favorite SwanQueen fanfics to The Hollywood Mag. (if you want)

    The Princess and The Prisoner by: Chrmdpoet https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9425314/1/The-Princess-and-The-Prisoner

    Double Trouble by: sea-ess-eye https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9189219/1/Double-Trouble

    A Fine Line by: hunnyfresh https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9095819/1/A-Fine-Line

    Angel with dirty hands by: Bond.Jane https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9791333/1/Angel-with-dirty-hands

    These are just a few of my favorites, I could post more but I want to let others a chance to post theirs. 🙂

  47. SwenLife

    August 6, 2015 at 9:10 pm

    Viva La Swan Queen! <3 Emma x Regina, my OTP <3

  48. Kynt

    August 7, 2015 at 2:16 pm

    Only 1 het ship and no slash ship? Did I miss the part where they explain why Sherlock (41k+ H/W slash fics on AO3) wasn’t nominated?

  49. JustSayBisexual

    August 8, 2015 at 1:29 pm

    Thank you to the group of CSers who accepts SQ as a valid ship. Y’all are great.

    To the CSers who are just here to be rude… what is the point of you being here? This is a poll about non-canon ships (all of which are femslash except one which is kinda weird). CS is canon.

  50. tiffany

    August 12, 2015 at 2:01 am

    I believe that Xena an Gabbrile should be cannon they have died an came back for each other
    even in death they did not leave each other they return.

    i dont believe that any of the others has done so dying an coming back to life for the other is the reason an what we all should all reconize to be the proper for that of cannon

    if the others have same qulitys they will have to prove to as that of equal of what xena an gabbrile had done for each other then i would say that they have right to be canon but until they reach the same level as xena an gabbrile i would say no to it becasue they did not die an come back to life for that of the other

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *